Deciding whether to keep, downgrade, or cancel a credit card isn’t always straightforward. If you’re earning points, managing annual fees, and thinking about your credit score, this decision can have a major impact on your finances and rewards strategy.

In this guide, I’ll walk you through expert strategies and real-world scenarios to help you make the smartest choice for your wallet and travel goals.

Important: Don’t Lose Your Points Before Canceling

Before closing any rewards card, ensure you transfer or combine your points to another active account. Many issuers forfeit your rewards the moment your card is closed—so take this step seriously.

Action Tip: Contact your card issuer and ask:

“Can I transfer or combine my points to another account before I close this card?”

A quick call or secure message can preserve hundreds—or thousands—of dollars in rewards.

What to Do Before Closing a Credit Card

Before you cancel, there are key steps to take that can either save the card or prepare you to close it without damaging your credit.

Check for a Retention Offer

Credit card issuers often offer retention bonuses to keep customers. These can include:

• Bonus points after meeting a spend requirement
• A waived or reduced annual fee
• A statement credit or other incentive

How to Request a Retention Offer

• American Express: Use the secure chat feature in your account.
• Chase, Citi, Capital One, etc.: Call customer service or send a secure message.

Pro Tip: Use this sample script when calling:

“Hi, I’ve really enjoyed using the [Card Name], especially for [travel perks, rewards, etc.]. I’m reviewing my budget and considering closing the card due to the annual fee. Are there any retention offers available that could help me decide to keep it open?”

Even if no offer is available, you’ve lost nothing by asking.

When to Keep an Annual Fee Credit Card

Sometimes, the value you get from your card outweighs the fee. Here are scenarios where it’s worth holding onto the card:

1. You Use a Free Night Certificate or Annual Travel Credit

Example: The World of Hyatt Card offers a free night that can easily be worth $300+, while the annual fee is only $95.

2. You Need Access to Transfer Partners

Cards like the Chase Sapphire Preferred or Amex Gold unlock airline and hotel transfer partners—key for maximizing point value.

3. You Use Airport Lounge Access Frequently

If you fly regularly, the Amex Platinum or Capital One Venture X lounge access can deliver hundreds in value per trip.

4. You Rely on Built-In Travel Protections

Some cards offer:

• Trip delay/cancellation insurance
• Lost luggage coverage
• Rental car insurance

These perks can easily save you hundreds during unexpected travel hiccups.

When to Downgrade a Credit Card Instead

If you’re not getting value from your premium card, downgrading can be a strategic move that protects your credit score.

Benefits of Downgrading:

• Preserve Your Credit History & Credit Line – Great for your credit score
• Avoid Annual Fees – Many no-annual-fee versions still earn decent rewards
• Stay in the Issuer’s Ecosystem – Useful for future product changes or bonus eligibility

Example Scenario:

You have the Chase Sapphire Reserve but no longer travel as much. Downgrade to Chase Freedom Unlimited and still earn rewards without the $550 fee.

When to Cancel a Credit Card

Canceling should be your last resort, but here are two smart reasons to consider it:

1. The Card No Longer Provides Any Value

• You don’t use the benefits
• No downgrade options exist
• You’ve already moved your points

Example: You have a co-branded airline card for an airline you no longer fly. No travel, no perks, no reason to keep paying.

2. To Reset the Clock on a Welcome Bonus

Some issuers have waiting periods for sign-up bonuses. You may need to cancel your card before applying again.

Popular Card Bonus Waiting Periods:

• Chase Sapphire Preferred / Reserve: Once every 48 months
• Capital One Venture / Venture X: Every 48 months
• Chase Ink Cards: Every 24 months
• Southwest Personal & Business Cards: Every 24 months

💡 Pro Tip: The waiting period starts from when you last earned the bonus, not when you opened or canceled the card.

Final Tips for Long-Term Credit Card Strategy

1. Track Annual Fee Dates

Use tools like Travel Freely, AwardWallet, or even Google Calendar to monitor when your annual fees post so you can act early.

2. Reevaluate Cards Every Year

Ask yourself:

• Did I use the benefits enough to justify the fee?
• Are better alternatives available now?
• Can I earn a new bonus by switching?

3. Think Long-Term: Points, Credit, and Perks

Sometimes the best decision isn’t about this year—it’s about maintaining relationships with issuers and setting yourself up for bigger rewards later.

---

Summary: Keep, Downgrade, or Cancel?

Scenario	Keep	Downgrade	Cancel
You regularly use travel perks	✅	❌	❌
You want to avoid the annual fee but keep your credit line	❌	✅	❌
You’ve earned the bonus and want to start the clock for reapplying	❌	❌	✅
The card has a valuable free night or travel credit	✅	❌	❌
You never use the card and it’s costing you money	❌	❌	✅

---

Final Thoughts

Managing credit cards is more than just avoiding fees—it’s about maximizing value. Whether you decide to keep, downgrade, or cancel a card, always align your decision with your overall travel and rewards strategy.

A thoughtful approach can mean the difference between a $95 card that costs you money… and one that earns you a $1,000 trip every year.